- · 5008 friends
Brief Reasons Are Not Inadequate Reasons: Property Appeal Fails, and the Wife's Overlooked $100,962 in Crypto Undercuts Her "Plainly Unjust" Claim
In Velery & Velery [2026] FedCFamC1A 205, the Full Court (Williams, Kari & McNab JJ) dismissed a wife's appeal from property orders made by a judge of the Family Court of Western Australia in Velery and Velery [2026] FCWA 119 ([1], [6], [104]). She argued that the reasons were inadequate, that her tax debt and a $303,000 loan from her mother were not brought to account, and that the husband's 2017 inheritance could not justify a 55/45 contribution finding in his favour ([42], [60], [71], [88]). Every ground failed. The husband's Notice of Contention, which showed that the primary judge had overlooked a second tranche of the wife's cryptocurrency worth $100,962, "enjoys merit", and the wife conceded the error ([34]–[36]). That conceded error made her claim that the result was "unreasonable or plainly unjust" harder, not easier ([35], [101]). There was no order as to costs ([105]). All paragraph references below are to the judgment.
Why it matters: "My reasons complaint" is one of the most common appeal grounds, and one of the most often rejected. This judgment shows why. Reasons that are "economically stated" are adequate if the appeal court can follow how the judge got there ([56]–[58]). A party is bound by how they ran the case at trial ([65]). And before arguing that an outcome is plainly unjust, check the asset list. Here the overlooked asset was the appellant's own ([35], [101]).
🧩 Facts and Issues
The relationship
- The parties began living together in 2006, married in 2008 and separated in early 2020. They have three children, and the wife is the primary carer ([7], [22]).
- The husband received gifts from his parents in 2007 and 2008, which helped buy the parties' first home in Victoria ([9]–[10]). The family later moved to Western Australia and lived rent-free with the wife's parents for 13 months ([11]–[12]). In 2014 the parties and the wife's parents bought a home together, with the parties holding 30 per cent ([14]).
- In 2017 the husband inherited about AUD550,000 ([18]).
- During the marriage the parties built interests in several hospitality businesses. Their interest in the main venue was valued at $2,251,000 in May 2021, $1,473,000 in June 2022 and nil by March 2025. Two later venues were also valued at nil ([19], [25]–[26]).
Debts and legal costs
- After separation the wife borrowed $303,000 from her mother, mainly for legal fees. She also had tax liabilities of $249,904 and debts to her accountant and the single expert ([27]).
- The husband had a personal tax liability of $126,557 and loan accounts of $175,371 and $125,713 owed to two of the businesses ([28]).
- The Full Court described the legal costs below as "extravagantly disproportionate". The wife spent $680,907 and the husband $524,588, together just short of the whole pool, and the Court said both parties had prioritised legal fees over their tax obligations ([37], [53]).
The trial and orders
- The trial ran over four days in July 2025. Orders were made with reasons on 2 June 2026 ([29]).
- The primary judge left the parties' post-separation personal liabilities out of the revised balance sheet of $1,251,302, assessed contributions at 55/45 in the husband's favour, and divided the pool 60/40 in the wife's favour ([45], [57], [82], [101]).
- The wife's allegation that the husband's conduct was coercive and controlling was "robustly" rejected at trial. It was not a ground of appeal ([21], [81]).
- Child support departure orders made at the same time were not challenged ([2]–[3]).
Developments revealed on appeal
- At the appeal hearing it emerged that the companies running the hospitality venues had entered voluntary administration in 2026. The Court said the husband "was neither forthcoming nor candid" about this, and he had not applied to adduce further evidence ([20], [25]–[26], [100]).
Issues
- Grounds 2 and 3: did the primary judge fail to take into account the wife's tax debt and the $303,000 loan from her mother, or fail to give adequate reasons about them ([42])?
- Ground 4: was it an error to include funds held in the wife's solicitor's trust account ([60])?
- Grounds 5 and 5A: was the 55/45 contribution finding open, given how the inheritance was used, and were the reasons adequate ([70]–[71], [88])?
- Ground 7: was the result "unreasonable or plainly unjust" because the husband kept all the income-producing businesses ([94]–[95])?
- Notice of Contention: did the primary judge overlook a tranche of the wife's cryptocurrency ([30]–[31])?
Grounds 1 and 6 were abandoned ([41], [93]).
⚖️ Applicable Law – Legislation, Regulations, Rules
- Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) Pt VIII and s 79 — property adjustment. The Court must take into account the nature and circumstances of liabilities incurred by the parties (s 79(3)(b) and s 79(5)) ([2], [57]).
- Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) s 95 and Family Court Act 1997 (WA) s 211C — the overarching purpose provisions, which the Court said the parties' legal spending showed "a blatant disregard" for ([37]).
- Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) s 114UB — the presumption that each party bears their own costs in an appeal ([105]).
📌 Precedents Relied On
- House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499 — appealable error in a discretionary decision, including an outcome that is "unreasonable or plainly unjust" ([40], [94]).
- Australian Coal and Shale Employees' Federation v The Commonwealth (1953) 94 CLR 621 — a judgment is presumed correct unless material error is shown, and the appellant bears the onus ([39]).
- Sun Alliance Insurance Ltd v Massoud [1989] VR 8, Bennett & Bennett (1991) FLC 92-191 and Fowles & Fowles (No 2) (2024) FLC 94-198 — reasons are inadequate if the appeal court cannot ascertain the reasoning, and must do justice to the issues ([56]).
- Pollard v RRR Corporation Pty Ltd [2009] NSWCA 110 — a judge need not spell out every detail of the reasoning ([56]).
- Steinbrenner & Steinbrenner [2008] FamCAFC 193 — explaining the "leap" from a qualitative evaluation to figures ([52]).
- Han & Han (2026) FLC 94-310 — taking into account the nature and circumstances of the parties' liabilities ([57]).
- Metwally v University of Wollongong (1985) 60 ALR 68 — a party is bound by the conduct of their case ([65]).
- Edwards v Noble (1971) 125 CLR 296 and Robinson Helicopter Co v McDermott (2016) 331 ALR 550 — a factual finding stands if it was reasonably open, unless it is "glaringly improbable or contrary to compelling inferences" ([73]–[74]).
- Gronow v Gronow (1979) 144 CLR 513 — weight is quintessentially for the primary judge ([86]).
- Franc & Franc [2026] FedCFamC1A 159, Horrigan & Horrigan [2020] FamCAFC 25, Hendrix & Haroldson [2025] FedCFamC1A 160 and Dickons & Dickons (2012) 50 Fam LR 244 — contributions are assessed holistically, not by valuing each contribution mathematically or adding up percentages factor by factor ([75], [90]–[91]).
🧠 Analysis
Issue
Did the wife show appealable error in how the primary judge dealt with debts, trust funds, the inheritance and the overall result? And what was the effect of the husband's Notice of Contention about the overlooked cryptocurrency?
Rule
- The appellant must establish material error of the House v The King kind. It is not enough that the appeal court might have taken a different course ([39]–[40]).
- Reasons are adequate if the appeal court can ascertain the reasoning on which the decision is based ([56]).
- A factual finding stands if it was reasonably open on the evidence ([73]–[74]), and weight is for the primary judge ([86]).
- A party is bound by how they ran their case at trial, except in the most exceptional circumstances ([65]).
Application
The debts were taken into account, even if not all were mentioned in one place
The wife's counsel clarified that the complaint was not about excluding her personal debts from the revised balance sheet ([46]). Her trial counsel had effectively accepted that she should bear the debt to her mother alone ([46]–[47]). The complaint was that the primary judge did not mention her tax liability in the s 79(5) discussion, while he did mention the husband's tax liabilities ([48]).
The Full Court accepted that the tax liability was not mentioned at that point, but held that the reasons showed the judge was "acutely aware" of both parties' personal liabilities. He set them out in detail, noted that "[b]oth parties have significant debts" and then calculated the effect of the proposed division ([49]–[52]). Those calculations showed the move from a qualitative evaluation to numbers ([52]). The Court also observed that the wife's tax debt arose largely because she paid legal fees instead of tax ([53]).
Brief reasons can still be adequate reasons
The primary judge explained why personal debts were excluded: neither party should be responsible for debts incurred by the other ([57]). The Full Court said that, while "economically stated", the reasoning could be followed, particularly given the five or so years since separation and the diversion of income to legal fees ([58]). Grounds 2 and 3 failed ([59]).
You are bound by how you ran your case
Ground 4 attacked the inclusion of $63,476 held in the wife's solicitor's trust account. But both parties' trust funds were in the joint balance sheet, and the wife's counsel had told the trial judge the trust funds were "real existing funds" that belonged at the top of the balance sheet ([62]–[63]). Counsel could not point to any contrary submission at trial ([64]). The wife was bound by the way she ran her case, and no exceptional circumstances were shown ([65]–[66]). There was also no direct evidence the trust funds came from her mother's loan, and no reasons were needed for including an agreed item ([67]–[68]). Ground 4 failed ([69]).
The inheritance finding was open on the evidence
The husband's evidence of how the 2017 inheritance was used had not been challenged at trial, and the Full Court inferred that the primary judge accepted it ([79]–[80]). The inherited funds had been placed in an offset account and later a savings account, and $536,847 traced to the inheritance was still in the bank at trial ([80], [82]). Against a pool of $1,251,302, or $1,352,264 with the second cryptocurrency tranche, a 55/45 contribution finding for the husband could not be called "glaringly improbable or contrary to compelling inferences" ([82]).
The weight challenge failed because the primary judge had weighed every contribution the parties raised, including the wife's parents' help to the family, and weight is for the trial judge ([81], [84]–[87]). The reasons complaint under Ground 5 failed too. The Court said it did "not fully understand" it, because the reasoning was "readily discernible" ([89]). A judge who valued each contribution mathematically, or added up separate percentages for each factor, would have erred ([90]–[91]). Grounds 5 and 5A failed ([92]).
The Notice of Contention: the wife's overlooked crypto
The primary judge recorded the wife's cryptocurrency at $12,617 in both balance sheets. Later, in his reasons, he recorded it as $100,962 ([32]–[34]). The Full Court found this was "clearly a factual mistake": one of two tranches in the parties' joint balance sheet, $12,617 and $100,962, had been disregarded ([34]). The wife's counsel conceded during the appeal that she held the additional $100,962 ([35]).
The husband did not cross-appeal, and his Notice of Contention did not seek to change the orders ([5], [30]). Instead, the Court used the conceded error in two places. First, it used the larger pool of $1,352,264 when testing the contribution finding ([82]). Second, and decisively, it used it under Ground 7. The 60/40 division in the wife's favour had been calculated without the $100,962, which she kept on top of her share ([101]). The concession was "financially advantageous" to her, but it "undermined her contention" that the result was unreasonable and plainly unjust ([35]).
"Plainly unjust" failed on the real numbers
The wife argued that the husband kept all the income-producing businesses and their benefits ([95]–[96]). The Court found the primary judge was "alive to" the debt attached to those businesses and to the wife's "more stable financial future" ([98]). At trial she had not sought to keep any of the businesses ([99]). By the appeal, the companies behind most of the venues had been in voluntary administration. The Court said the "house of cards which juggled unsustainable debt" had come to fruition, and that the wife had kept her earning capacity without being "saddled with" heavily indebted assets ([100]). With the 60/40 division and the extra cryptocurrency, the result was "well within the range" ([101]). A reasons complaint raised only in written submissions, and not in the Amended Notice of Appeal, was not separately addressed ([102]). Ground 7 failed ([103]).
Costs
The husband sought costs. Having regard to both parties' financial circumstances and the other s 114UB(3) considerations, the Court was not persuaded to displace the presumption in s 114UB and made no order as to costs ([105]).
Conclusion
The appeal was dismissed as "wholly lacking in merit", with no order as to costs ([104]–[105], Orders 1–2).
The Notice of Contention succeeded only in the sense that the Court found it "enjoys merit" and relied on the conceded error to reject the appeal ([36], [101]). The property orders were not varied. The judgment does not decide anything about the child support departure orders ([3]). It does not make findings about the current value of the husband's business interests after the administrations ([20], [100]).
🧠 Take-Home Lesson
- "Economically stated" reasons are not inadequate reasons. The test is whether the appeal court can follow the reasoning ([56]–[58]).
- Read the whole judgment before saying something was ignored. The wife's debts were dealt with across several paragraphs, not in one place ([49]–[52]).
- You are bound by how you ran your case. An item you agreed to at trial cannot become an error on appeal ([63]–[66]).
- Unchallenged evidence at trial is hard to attack later. The husband's account of the inheritance was not tested at trial ([80]).
- Do not ask for a mathematical breakdown of contributions. Holistic assessment is the law ([90]–[91]).
- Check the asset list before arguing "plainly unjust". A respondent can use a Notice of Contention to show the result was more favourable to you than it looked ([34]–[36], [101]).
- Legal costs can swallow the pool. Here combined costs were just short of the property available for division ([37]).
- Self-represented litigants and support workers: before drafting a reasons ground, point to the paragraph where the reasoning is missing and explain why that gap changed the result ([56], [89]).
"Brief reasons are not inadequate reasons. If the appeal court can follow the path, the ground fails."
"Before you argue the outcome was plainly unjust, make sure the court has counted everything, including your own assets."
