- · 5007 friends
Removed Overseas Without Consent: Court Orders Child's Return From a Non-Convention Country, but Won't Switch Interim Care to the Mother
In Christinsen & Nykvist [2026] FedCFamC1F 653, Anderson J dealt with a mother's interim application after the father allegedly took the parties' 11-year-old daughter to Country B in February 2026 without her knowledge or consent ([1]–[2]). Country B is not a party to the 1996 Child Protection Convention ([20]). The result: the Court held it had jurisdiction under s 111CD(1)(e) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) because the child is an Australian citizen and remains habitually resident in Australia ([23], [25], [27]). It ordered the father to return the child to the Sydney metropolitan area by 4.00 pm on 30 October 2026 ([3], [36]; Order 1). But it refused, at that stage, to place the child in the mother's primary care on her return. Until the interim hearing, the child is to live with the father and spend time with the mother as agreed ([37]–[38]; Order 2). The important point is that a child's removal overseas does not end the Court's reach where habitual residence is still in Australia. A parent who stays silent and does not take part risks an undefended hearing or a warrant for their arrest ([42]; Notes C–D). All paragraph references below are to the judgment.
Why it matters: When a child is taken to a country outside the international family law conventions, left-behind parents are often told there is "nothing the Australian court can do". This judgment shows a practical pathway. Identify the jurisdictional provision (here s 111CD(1)(e)), prove Australian citizenship and habitual residence with concrete evidence, serve the other parent by every channel the Court allows, and ask for precise return orders ([14], [23]–[27], [40]). It also carries a warning for applicants. Serious family violence allegations are weighed against how the applicant actually behaved after separation. The mother had accepted the child living with the father, so the Court would not change the child's primary carer on interim, untested evidence ([37]).
🧩 Facts and Issues
The family
- The mother is 39 and the father is 50. They met in Country B in 2003 and married by religious ceremony in 2004. The mother says the marriage was "legalised" in Australia in 2005 ([4]). The father migrated to Australia in December 2004 ([5]).
- There are five children, aged 21, 20, 18, 16 and 11. The mother sought orders only for the youngest, an 11-year-old girl referred to as Y ([6]).
- The parties separated finally in October 2024 ([7]). The mother says she was the children's primary carer during the relationship. The Court noted it had no evidence to test that assertion ([8]).
The alleged violence and the post-separation arrangements
- The mother alleges that the father was verbally, emotionally, physically and controllingly abusive during the relationship, including three alleged physical assaults between 2023 and October 2024 ([9]). These are allegations. The father filed no evidence, and the Court made no findings about them.
- After separation the children stayed in the former home at Suburb F. The mother says she visited about twice a week, and did not start parenting proceedings because she was "frightened" of more conflict and worried about damaging her relationship with the children ([10]).
- In January 2025 the father travelled to Country B. The mother moved back into the home and cared for the children full-time until about June 2025, when, she says, the father "forced" her out on his return ([11], [25(b)]). She says he changed the locks in June 2025 ([38]).
The removal
- In February 2026 the father took four of the children to Country B ([12]). All but Y and the 18-year-old came back in May 2026. The 16-year-old now lives with a maternal uncle in Australia ([12]).
- The mother says she has had no communication with Y since February 2026 ([13]). In an early 2026 phone call, the child said words to the effect of "I can't call you" ([28]).
- The mother believes Y is attending school in Country B, but she was not consulted and does not know which school ([26]). The father ignored letters from her solicitors ([26]).
The procedural history
- The mother filed on 17 July 2026. Her first application was "improperly drawn", and it was agreed that her first affidavit contained factual errors and did not deal with ss 111CC or 111CD ([14]). The Court ordered an amended application "identifying with precision the orders sought" and a further affidavit addressing those sections ([14]).
- The amended documents were filed on 20 August 2026 and served under the Court's orders ([15]–[16]). The father filed nothing and did not appear on 29 July or 21 August 2026 ([16]; Note B). The Court decided the return application without his participation ([16]).
Issues
- Does the Court have jurisdiction to make parenting orders for a child who is now in a non-Convention country ([17(a)], [19]–[27])?
- Is it in the child's best interests to make an interim order requiring the father to return her to New South Wales ([17(b)], [28]–[36])?
- If so, what interim arrangements are in her best interests on her return ([17(c)], [37]–[38])?
- What orders are needed to move the case along quickly, given that the father is not taking part ([18], [40]–[43])?
⚖️ Applicable Law – Legislation, Regulations, Rules
- s 69E of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth): sets out the Court's jurisdiction in parenting matters. Because Y is an Australian citizen, s 69E(1)(b) is satisfied ([19], [23]).
- Pt XIIIAA, Subdivision B, and s 111CC: the Child Protection Convention limits the Court's jurisdiction. Subdivision B applies when the question is whether the Court, as opposed to an authority of a Convention or non-Convention country, has jurisdiction to take measures to protect a child ([19]).
- s 111CD(1)(e): for a child present in a non-Convention country, the Court may exercise jurisdiction only if the child is habitually resident in Australia and one of s 69E(1)(b) to (e) applies. The test is conjunctive ([22]–[23]).
- s 60CC: the child's best interests are the paramount consideration, assessed by reference to the s 60CC matters ([30]).
- s 60CG: so far as consistent with best interests, an order must be consistent with any family violence order and must not expose a person to an unacceptable risk of family violence ([31]).
- s 62G: the basis for directing the parties and the child to attend a Court Child Expert for a Child Impact Report (Order 3).
- s 67ZBD: orders requiring the NSW Department of Communities and Justice and NSW Police to tell the Court about documents or information on abuse, neglect, family violence and risk ([43]; Orders 13–16).
- Part XIVB / s 114Q: publication is under the pseudonym Christinsen & Nykvist. It is an offence to publish an account that identifies the parties, associated persons or witnesses (cover notes).
📌 Precedents Relied On
The Court relied on these authorities:
- Kurtis & Aldo [2025] FedCFamC1F 621: the Child Protection Convention constrains the Court's jurisdiction where the child is in a foreign jurisdiction, and s 111CD(1)(e) is conjunctive (at [30]) ([19], [23]).
- LK v Director-General, Department of Community Services (2009) 237 CLR 582 at [23]–[28], [35]–[36]: the leading High Court authority on habitual residence ([24]).
- Secretary, Department of Families, Fairness and Housing & Whiting [2024] FedCFamC1F 479: Williams J's analysis of LK ([24]).
- Franklyn & Franklyn [2019] FamCAFC 256 at [73]: at an interim hearing, decide on agreed facts, less contentious evidence and fair inferences where possible. Decisions must still be made despite contentious evidence, and weak evidence may be treated as weak ([33]).
🧠 Analysis
Issue
When one parent takes a child to a country that is not a party to the Child Protection Convention, and then ignores the Australian proceedings, can the Court still make parenting orders? If it can, should it order the child's return and immediately change her primary carer on the left-behind parent's untested evidence?
Rule
Because Y was present in a non-Convention country, the Court could exercise jurisdiction only under s 111CD(1)(e). That required both habitual residence in Australia and one of s 69E(1)(b) to (e) ([21]–[23]). Habitual residence is assessed under LK ([24]). Once jurisdiction is established, best interests are paramount (s 60CC), and s 60CG requires orders that do not expose a person to an unacceptable risk of family violence ([30]–[31]). At an interim hearing, serious allegations cannot be ignored because they are untested, but a cautious approach applies, and the Court acts on the strength of the evidence actually before it (Franklyn; [32]–[33]).
Application
Getting the application right came first
The case did not start well. The first application was "improperly drawn", and the affidavit did not help the Court decide whether to exercise jurisdiction over a child living overseas ([14]). The Court sent the mother away to file an amended application "identifying with precision the orders sought" and an affidavit addressing ss 111CC and 111CD ([14]). Only once that was done could the return application be heard ([15]–[16]).
A competent authority overseas did not oust the Court
Country B is not a signatory to the Child Protection Convention. The Court said it was implicit in the mother's evidence that a competent authority exists in Country B, but no proceedings had been started there ([20]). The mother said she had not been served with any Country B application and knew of no Country B order about Y. She had not gone to Country B's courts herself because she feared she might have to stay there for the length of the case ([20]). That meant s 111CD had to be satisfied for this Court to have jurisdiction ([21]).
Citizenship was easy, so habitual residence decided it
Y's Australian citizenship satisfied s 69E(1)(b) "readily" ([23]). The real question was habitual residence ([23]). The Court relied on:
- her birth in Australia, and having lived nowhere else apart from a two-month holiday in 2017 ([25(a)]);
- care by both parents in Australia after separation ([25(b)]);
- attendance at the same local school since kindergarten, friends, and regular contact with extended family in Australia ([25(c)]);
- the mother's evidence that the parents never discussed or agreed to a permanent move ([25(d)]).
Against that, the Country B connections were thin. The mother believed Y was at school there and living with paternal family, but that belief was "without evidentiary foundation" ([26]). The Court found the Country B connections were not "sufficiently strong to cause the loss of habitual residence in Australia", noting the mother never intended Y to live overseas ([27]). Jurisdiction was established ([27]).
Return was in the child's best interests
The Court was concerned that, pending a final hearing, "a status quo will be created by reason of the child's location in Country B" ([34]). More importantly, it was not satisfied that staying there was in Y's best interests. Three of her four siblings, her maternal grandmother, uncles, aunt and cousins are in Australia ([34]). There was also a "lacuna in the evidence" about her ability to remain in Country B. On the mother's evidence, Y holds no Country B passport, and the Court had no evidence of the father's citizenship status ([34]).
The key finding was that Y "is at risk of harm in Country B by dint of the father's conduct in depriving the child of a relationship with her mother, siblings and extended members of the maternal family", and by removing her from the community she lived in before February 2026 ([35]). The Court ordered her return, giving the father until 4.00 pm on 30 October 2026 to make arrangements. That timing also let him prepare for a property conciliation conference listed for 15 October 2026 ([36]; Order 1).
Allegations were weighed against the mother's own conduct
The mother wanted Y placed in her primary care on arrival, with the father's time supervised at a contact centre ([13], [29], [37]). She made serious allegations of family violence. But the Court said those allegations had to be considered alongside her conduct after October 2024. "On its face", her acquiescence to the child living with the father was inconsistent with a claim that the child faced such a risk that her primary carer should change ([37]). The Court also noted that, after about 15 months, it was being asked to change the child's primary carer, and that doing so might require police involvement ([29], [37]). It was not satisfied that this was in Y's best interests at that point ([37]).
The interim result: return, then back with the father pending a hearing
On return, and until the balance of the interim applications can be heard, Y is to live with the father and spend time with the mother as agreed (Order 2). The father controls the Suburb F home, so the Court was satisfied he could accommodate himself and the child ([38]). Once he files his material, the Court can hear argument on parenting and on the mother's application for sale of the property ([38]; Order 18).
Non-participation has consequences
The father was served by email, Facebook Messenger and WhatsApp ([40]; Orders 10–12). Despite the Court's efforts, he "failed to engage" ([41]). The Court ordered a Child Impact Report anyway, "with an expectation that the father complies" ([42]; Orders 3–9), and extended his time to file to 7 October 2026 (Order 17). It warned that if he did not comply, the case may proceed undefended on the mother's evidence and a warrant may issue for his arrest ([42]; Notes C–D). Section 67ZBD orders were made against NSW Police and the Department of Communities and Justice so that all relevant information would be gathered promptly ([43]; Orders 13–16). An interim defended hearing was listed for 4 December 2026 (Order 18).
Conclusion
The Court had jurisdiction because Y is an Australian citizen who remains habitually resident in Australia, despite being in a non-Convention country since February 2026 ([23], [27]). Her return was in her best interests because keeping her in Country B entrenched a status quo that cut her off from her mother, siblings and community ([34]–[36]). But the mother's untested allegations, read against her own acceptance of the father's care after separation, did not justify an immediate change of primary carer ([37]). The father must return Y, take part in a Child Impact Report and file his case, or face the prospect of an undefended hearing and an arrest warrant ([42]; Orders 1–18; Notes C–D).
🧠 Take-Home Lesson
- Removal overseas does not end the Court's reach. For a child in a non-Convention country, s 111CD(1)(e) gives jurisdiction if the child is habitually resident in Australia and a s 69E(1)(b) to (e) link exists, such as citizenship ([22]–[23], [27]).
- Habitual residence is proved with ordinary facts. Birthplace, years of schooling, friends, extended family, a short time overseas, and no agreement to relocate ([25]–[27]).
- Draft precisely and address jurisdiction head-on. A vague application and an affidavit that ignores ss 111CC and 111CD will be sent back, and time is lost while the child is overseas ([14]).
- Act early, because delay builds a status quo. The Court was concerned that the child's location overseas would harden into the arrangement pending a final hearing ([34]).
- A return order is not a change of carer. Return and interim care are separate questions, and the Court answered them differently ([36]–[37]; Orders 1–2).
- Your conduct after separation is evidence. Accepting the child living with the other parent can undercut a later claim that the child is at such risk that care should change immediately ([37]).
- Allegations are not findings. The mother's family violence allegations were untested, the father filed nothing, and the Court made no findings on them ([8]–[9], [16], [37]).
- Ignoring the case is risky. Substituted service by email, Messenger and WhatsApp, deemed service, a Child Impact Report, s 67ZBD orders, and warnings of an undefended hearing and arrest warrant all followed ([40]–[43]; Orders 10–17; Notes C–D).
- Support workers and McKenzie friends: when a child has been taken overseas, help the left-behind parent gather evidence of citizenship and of the child's life in Australia (school, friends, family, travel history), keep a record of every attempt to contact the child and the other parent, and seek legal advice early about jurisdiction and the precise return orders to ask for ([14], [25]–[28]).
"I am satisfied that the child, Y, is at risk of harm in Country B by dint of the father's conduct in depriving the child of a relationship with her mother, siblings and extended members of the maternal family." ([35])
"Taking a child overseas does not take the child out of the Court's reach. Habitual residence is the key, and ordinary evidence proves it." (FLAST takeaway)
